A Bottom-Up History of Credit Reporting
In 2017, Equifax, one of the world’s largest credit reporters, publicly revealed that cyberhackers broke through its cybersecurity system and ran off with the personal information of approximately 148 million Americans. Consequently, there has been a growing public awareness of the ways in which we are all enmeshed in the surveillance infrastructure of the credit reporting industry and how assumptions about creditworthiness dictate everything from our employment opportunities to how much we pay for a new mobile phone.[1]
Of course, for people disproportionately disadvantaged by the norms of credit reporting, including Black and Latinx Americans, immigrants, women, and poor and working-class people, such revelations about the power of credit reporting were neither new nor surprising. Indeed, a major impetus behind my writing about Barbara Collins and her 1972 encounter with the Retail Credit Company (RCC)–the subject of my recent JWH article–was to highlight this fact and to better understand what a bottom-up perspective of credit reporting, and the closely related insurance industry, could tell us about twentieth-century capitalism.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, then, the archival encounter that sparked my interest in credit reporting’s history occurred while researching the social history of queer community organizing around employment discrimination. I was at the New York Public Library (NYPL) in 2013, looking through the papers of the Gay Activists Alliance (GAA), when one of their press releases caught my attention. It detailed a GAA-organized “zap” against the New York-based investigation agency, Fidelifacts, in 1971. In particular, GAA members were angry, since Fidelifacts used invasive surveillance techniques to gather the personal information of individuals, including details about a person’s sex life, which the company then sold to employers, insurers, and banks. The GAA contended that such practices constituted discrimination, and their actions against Fidelifacts sought to raise public support for a city-wide law prohibiting discrimination in hiring, housing, and lending based on sexual orientation.[2]
The GAA press release raised new questions for me. How did a person’s “private” life shape their ability to navigate market society? How did the people most marginalized by this type of information reporting experience and confront this system of economic power?
Following my time at the NYPL, I started searching for Fidelifacts in readily available digitized and published sources, namely newspapers, government documents, and industry trade journals and magazines. These sources shed light on the much larger consumer information infrastructure of which Fidelifacts made up the tiniest of parts. There were much bigger companies such as the Retail Credit Company (renamed Equifax in 1976), which by the 1970s operated a robust global network of personal information storing and selling.
Trade press publications and company in-house magazines offered an abundance of material documenting the way in which reporters of information viewed and categorized people based on their personal lives and social relations.[3] Such sources presented clear evidence of the institutionalization of sexist and racist practices in what we now refer to as the credit reporting industry. However, published sources privileged the point of view of lawmakers and financial institutions. This was also the case with many of publicly accessible archives scholars use in writing about the history of credit reporting.[4]
I found that court case records–a cornerstone of social histories of race, gender, and class–provided a powerful lens through which to view twentieth-century credit reporting.[5] As I detail in the article, in 1973, Barbara Collins filed a lawsuit against RCC for violating her privacy and writing an erroneous investigation report that reduced her to a divorced, promiscuous alcoholic. As a result, an auto insurer deemed her too risky for a new policy. On the witness stand, Collins contested this portrait of her life, describing instead her small-town, working-class community as one filled with complex kinship and exchange networks that did not fit within the middle-class, nuclear family model proffered by RCC. More specifically, her witness testimony underscored the extent to which credit and insurance markets depend(ed) on misrecognition and the psychic harm this misrecognition engenders. Listening to Collins highlighted what histories of capitalism have to gain by centering their analyses on women’s experiences.
Ultimately, people like Collins have long known what the recent Equifax data breach brought to light for many others: that credit reporting companies can make financial life impossible.
To access the article, “The Barbara Collins Case: Regulating Women’s Lives in the Modern American Consumer Information and Insurance Markets” in the Spring 2021 Issue of the JWH, please click here.
[1] In particular, policymakers have started paying more attention to the dangers and inequalities embedded in the credit reporting industry. Recently, Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and other Democrats have proposed new legislation creating greater government oversight over the credit reporting industry. Further, in 2019, House Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), while serving as a member of the house Financial Services Committee, took to Twitter to highlight the stories of individuals negatively impacted by credit reporters’ assumptions about creditworthiness.
[2] Recently, the New York Public Library has made this story part of its NYC LGBT Historic Sites Project. https://www.nyclgbtsites.org/site/gay-activists-alliance-zap-at-fidelifacts-of-greater-new-york/.
[3] Literature scholar Jason Puskar notes in writing about the insurance industry that insurers, in particular, developed an extensive industry trade press that is useful for exploring the cultural history of finance. The credit reporting industry, too, propagated a sizeable trade press that I think should be used more in historical research. See Jason Puskar, “William Dean Howells and the Insurance of the Real,” American Literary History Vol 18, no. 1 (Spring 2006): 29-58.
[4] For example, many historians writing about the history of credit reporting, particularly in the nineteenth century, use the R.G. Dun & Co. and Dun & Bradstreet Collections, housed at the Baker Library at Harvard University. This collection contains thousands of nineteenth century credit reports but is sparser for the twentieth century. Further, the credit reports do not provide the point of view of the person being reported. In researching for the article, I also reached out to private corporations including Equifax about gaining permission to view archival material stored in house, but these archives are not open to public research.
[5] For helping me located Barbara Collins’ court case records, I would like to thank National Archives (NARA) archivist Leo Belleville. Leo helped me find the records at NARA-Chicago. Then, when I as a graduate student operating on a shoestring budget and couldn’t justify the expense of a research trip to Chicago to look at court case records which only tangentially relate to my dissertation, he scanned nearly a thousand of pages for me.