By Amanda Faulkner
This article examines the case of an enslaved woman named Claesje who was
accused of theft in New Netherland in 1652. Paying close attention to silences in the
court record and highlighting her words and actions outside of the courtroom, I argue
that we should reconsider her actions and motivations. Her case exemplifies how enslaved
women’s voices were reflected in and excluded from colonial records. Taken together, her
actions and speech represented an unconventional intervention in the court records.
I examine the important but precarious position of enslaved women within Dutch
colonial households, particularly because orderly households were considered the basis
for an orderly community. Disputes over jurisdiction in rural New Netherland spilled
over into the domestic sphere and likely affected Claesje’s fate. This article advances our
understanding of enslaved women’s lives in early America and of processes of record
making in the Dutch Atlantic World